A Rant About Worship Songs

This was pretty convicting to me, especially since I have the tendency in me to be a church snob.

From Jeremy Pierce:

Here are some of the things I really hate in a worship song.

1. Too simplistic, banal, lacking in depth, shallow, doctrineless: Consider that one that just talks about unity among brothers that only mentions God in passing at the very end.

2. It’s so repetitive. I mean, come on, how many times can you repeat “His steadfast love endures forever” before you start thinking the song is going to go on forever? Examples: here and here

3. For some songs, the focus is too much on instruments, and the sheer volume leads to its seeming more like a performance than worship and prevents quiet contemplation.

4. There might be too much emphasis on too intimate a relationship with God, using first-personme” and “I” or second-person pronouns like “you” instead of words like “we” and “God”. This fosters a spirit of individualism, and it generates an atmosphere of religious euphoria rather than actual worship of God. Worship should be about God, not about us. Or what about the ones that use physical language to describe God and our relationship with him? Can you really stomach the idea of tasting God? singular pronouns like “

5. Some songs have way too many words for anyone to learn.

6. It patterns its worship on experiences that not everyone in the congregation will be able to identify with. If you’re not in the frame of mind or don’t have the emotional state in question (e.g. a desperate longing for God. Then what are you doing lying and singing it? Worship leaders who encourage that sort of thing are making their congregations sing falsehoods.

7. Then there’s that song with the line asking God not to take the Holy Spirit away, as if God would ever do that to a genuine believer.

8. Then there’s that song that basically says nothing except expressing negative emotions.

At this point I’m so outraged that people would pass this sort of thing off as worship that I’m almost inclined to give in to the people who think we shouldn’t sing anything but the psalms. Oh, wait…

(HT TWax)

Bookmark and Share

4 Responses to “A Rant About Worship Songs”

  1. dip rippy Says:
    September 2nd, 2010 at 3:12 pm

    I’m a critic too… unless I’m leading. Doh! Did I just say that out loud? Oh the hypocrisy! Thanks for a good, revealing rant.

  2. Heather Says:
    September 2nd, 2010 at 8:51 pm

    I agree that some people complain too much about worship songs. That said, I have definitely said some of these things.

    For instance, I tend to be sensitive to sound, and it’s hard to worship when I have a headache from the loud bass.

    And I think repetitiveness is so hard for a worship leader to judge. While I don’t have a problem with repeating lyrics (some of the early worship songs were just repetitive chants) after singing “I’ll never know how much it cost to see my sin upon the cross” 100 times it stops losing meaning for me. But maybe the guy next to me needs to hear it 101 times to sink in – who should the worship leader accommodate?

  3. Tweets that mention Forward Progress » Blog Archive » A Rant About Worship Songs -- Topsy.com Says:
    September 3rd, 2010 at 6:07 am

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by cody davenport, Scott Spruill. Scott Spruill said: RT @codydavenport: Modern worship analysis. Well said. http://bit.ly/dw5RA4 [...]

  4. MK Says:
    September 3rd, 2010 at 7:06 am

    Great question, Heather. For my part, I’ll be cryptic and say everyone and no one. Everyone should have a point of relation, but everyone should also be stretched in different ways. But another important part of the discussion is the context of the church as assessed by the leadership. Perhaps part of the question must be “What do they need?” rather than just “What do they want?”

Leave a Reply




Switch to our mobile site